News Summary
NegativeCarvana delivered a strong Q3 2026 revenue beat (+42.4% YoY) with better-than-expected adjusted EBITDA, driving a 15.7% stock rally and multiple analyst upgrades to 'Buy' ratings. However, significant headwinds include an accounting investigation by BFA into earnings overstatement and related-party transaction irregularities, discovery of 140+ fraudulent Google Business listings across 39 states, full-year EBITDA guidance below consensus, and substantial insider selling ($45M+ in three months).
Red flags
- •BFA accounting investigation into potential earnings overstatement and improper related-party transaction accounting
- •140+ phantom Google Business Profile listings discovered spanning 39 states, suggesting systematic marketplace manipulation
- •Full-year EBITDA guidance of $2.85B below consensus of $2.93B despite Q3 beat
- •EPS miss of $0.06 (13% below consensus) despite revenue beat
- •Significant insider selling: $45.2M in executive stock sales over three months
- •Stock down 31% YTD prior to earnings bounce, underperforming peers CarMax (+34%) and AutoNation (-23%)
Funds Buying (7)
| Fund | Manager | Shares Held | ∆ Shares | Position Value | % of Fund | QoQ | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Viking Global | Andreas Halvorsen | 12.6M | +320K | $791M | 2.4% | +3% | Existing |
| Durable Capital Partners | Henry Ellenbogen | 7.3M | +596K | $458M | 4.7% | +9% | Existing |
| D1 Capital | Dan Sundheim | 4.1M | +361K | $259M | 0.8% | +10% | Existing |
| Maverick Capital | Lee Ainslie | 3.2M | +577K | $201M | 1.6% | +22% | Existing |
| Dragoneer | Marc Stad | 3.0M | +3.0M | $189M | 3.1% | — | NEW |
| Point72 | Steve Cohen | 69K | +69K | $4M | <0.1% | — | NEW |
| Glenview Capital | Larry Robbins | 10K | +10K | $1M | <0.1% | — | NEW |
Shares Held and Position Value reflect total quarter-end holdings. ∆ Shares is the change from the prior quarter. % of Fund is the position's share of the fund's reported equity portfolio — it drives the size weighting in the conviction score.
Portfolio Context
Where CVNA ranks in each buying fund's book, and the positions immediately around it. What a holding sits next to often says more about the thesis than the position size does.
position #8 of this fund's book
- 5META PLATFORMS INC$434M
- 6ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC$352M
- 7CEREBRAS SYSTEMS INC$235M
- 8CARVANA CO$189M
- 9INNIO NV$95M
- 10NU HLDGS LTD$63M
- 11CCC INTELLIGENT SOLUTIONS HL$61M
position #9 of this fund's book
- 6XPO INC$511M
- 7FERGUSON ENTERPRISES INC$485M
- 8MERCADOLIBRE INC$462M
- 9CARVANA CO$458M
- 10API GROUP CORP$443M
- 11SHOPIFY INC$442M
- 12AFFIRM HLDGS INC$283M
position #12 of this fund's book
- 9TESLA INC$831M
- 10MASTERCARD INCORPORATED$818M
- 11LENNOX INTL INC$809M
- 12CARVANA CO$791M
- 13MCDONALDS CORP$767M
- 14AMAZON COM INC$728M
- 15FEDEX CORP$723M
position #24 of this fund's book
- 21VIKING HOLDINGS LTD$315M
- 22DISNEY WALT CO$314M
- 23CLEAN HARBORS INC$283M
- 24CARVANA CO$259M
- 25AMAZON COM INC$250M
- 26THERMO FISHER SCIENTIFIC INC$234M
- 27CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP$208M
position #25 of this fund's book
- 22CAMDEN PPTY TR$230M
- 23DPC HOLDINGS PLC$217M
- 24RTX CORPORATION$212M
- 25CARVANA CO$201M
- 26THERMO FISHER SCIENTIFIC INC$201M
- 27VOYA FINANCIAL INC$167M
- 28LUMENTUM HLDGS INC$144M
Values are quarter-end position sizes. Shown only for funds where CVNA ranks inside their 40 largest equity positions — below that, neighbouring names carry no signal. Adjacency is an inference about a fund's reasoning, not a disclosure of it.
Funds Reducing / Exiting (3)
| Fund | Manager | Shares Held | ∆ Shares | Position Value | % of Fund | QoQ | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lone Pine Capital | Steve Mandel | 5.1M | -5,387,987 | $321M | 4.2% | -51% | Existing |
| Whale Rock Capital | Alex Sacerdote | 0 | −4.3M | — | 2.3% | -100% | EXITED |
| Duquesne Family Office | Stanley Druckenmiller | 0 | −151K | — | 0.2% | -100% | EXITED |
Shares Held reflects quarter-end positions for partial reductions. Funds that fully exited show 0 shares held. ∆ Shares is the change from the prior quarter. % of Fund is the prior-quarter position size — how much of the book was sold down.
Signal History
| Quarter | Direction | Funds | Score | vs SPY |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 2026 | SHORT | 3 | 3.33 | +14.9% |
| Q3 2026 | LONG | 7 | 8.37 | +14.9% |
| Q2 2026 | LONG | 9 | 12.65 | +8.1% |
| Q1 2026 | LONG | 6 | 8.50 | +0.5% |
Same issuer appearing in consecutive quarters — persistent institutional conviction. Returns are frozen at each archived quarter's last refresh.
Insider Activity
| Name | Title | Type | Shares | Price | Value | Filed | Src |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 5K | $71.80 | $0.35M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 8K | $73.01 | $0.60M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 7K | $73.98 | $0.53M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 2K | $74.67 | $0.13M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 4K | $70.78 | $0.30M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 1K | $76.06 | $0.11M | 2026-11-10 | ↗ |
| Taira Thomas | President, Special Projects | SELL | 6K | $75.74 | $0.42M | 2026-11-09 | ↗ |
| PLATT IRA J. | — | SELL | 15K | $74.32 | $1.11M | 2026-11-04 | ↗ |
| PLATT IRA J. | — | SELL | 15K | $77.21 | $1.13M | 2026-11-04 | ↗ |
| GILL DANIEL J. | Chief Product Officer | SELL | 254K | $71.46 | $18.13M | 2026-11-03 | ↗ |
| PLATT IRA J. | — | SELL | 15K | $71.32 | $1.07M | 2026-11-03 | ↗ |
| PLATT IRA J. | — | SELL | 15K | $72.16 | $1.08M | 2026-11-03 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 2K | $72.00 | $0.14M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 700 | $69.53 | $0.05M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 21K | $71.15 | $1.52M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 32K | $71.92 | $2.32M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 9K | $72.87 | $0.68M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 100 | $69.54 | $0.01M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 2K | $71.23 | $0.16M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 600 | $72.98 | $0.04M | 2026-11-02 | ↗ |
| QUAYLE J DANFORTH | — | SELL | 15K | $68.88 | $1.00M | 2026-10-30 | ↗ |
| Taira Thomas | President, Special Projects | SELL | 6K | $65.00 | $0.36M | 2026-10-12 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 920 | $59.48 | $0.05M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 840 | $60.75 | $0.05M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 920 | $61.64 | $0.06M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| Palmer Stephen R | Vice President of Accounting | SELL | 2K | $62.82 | $0.15M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 10K | $59.44 | $0.62M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 9K | $60.60 | $0.57M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 13K | $61.47 | $0.82M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 25K | $62.73 | $1.55M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| JENKINS MARK W. | Chief Financial Officer | SELL | 6K | $63.04 | $0.37M | 2026-10-01 | ↗ |
| MAROONE MICHAEL E | — | BUY | 21K | $61.69 | $1.30M | 2026-07-31 | ↗ |
| MAROONE MICHAEL E | — | BUY | 4K | $62.40 | $0.24M | 2026-07-31 | ↗ |
Beneficial Ownership (13D/13G)
| Filer | Form | Shares | % of Class | Filed | Src |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. | SC 13G/A | 79.9M | 11.1% | 2026-11-16 | ↗ |
| Ernest C. Garcia II | SC 13D/A | 212.2M | 22.7% | 2026-11-03 | ↗ |
| Capital Research Global Investors | SC 13G/A | 63.4M | 8.9% | 2026-08-12 | ↗ |
| BlackRock, Inc. | SC 13G/A | 44.9M | 6.3% | 2026-07-29 | ↗ |
SC 13D = active intent to influence control (10-day filing deadline after crossing 5%). SC 13G = passive accumulation, no intent to influence control.